My Spouse Makes Good Money. Do I Still Have To Pay Him or Her Alimony In My Naples, Florida Divorce?

Collier County Alimony

The Florida statute grants divorce courts broad discretion in awarding alimony.  Case law, however, curtails that broad discretion so that a more reasonable and consistent level of alimony can be estimated by family lawyers and applied by family law judges.

The first step in determining whether any alimony will be awarded is a quick comparison of the party’s incomes and assets.  If they are approximately equal, there will be no alimony award for either party.  Canakaris v. Canakaris, 382 So. 2d 1197 (Fla. 1980)

If there is a disparity in the couple’s income and financial assets then alimony may be awarded.  Alimony claims are made by comparing the two parties’ needs versus their respective financial resources, focusing primarily on recurring income and then on assets.

“Needs” is defined for the purposes of alimony as the standard of living that was enjoyed during the marriage.  Firestone v. Firestone, 263 So. 2d 223.  “Needs” in the alimony sense is obviously completely relative to the couple.  One man’s luxuries may be another man’s necessities.  The courts will apply a reasonable standard but it will always be tinged by the relative wealth or poverty of the lifestyle of the couple during the marriage.  In Naples, Florida, we have many residents of extreme wealth and income so it will be difficult to shock the court with a party’s needs, no matter how extreme.

Once the needs of a party are established, we then look to the capacity of the party with those needs to satisfy those needs with their own income and assets.

If the party seeking alimony can meet their needs with their own income, no alimony will be awarded.

If the party seeking alimony could foreseeably earn sufficient income to satisfy their needs, the court can impute that capacity to earn income to the spouse requesting alimony.  In my experience, proving a possibility is very difficult.  The best a high-earning spouse can do is request that the other spouse prepare a good-faith job diary to determine what income, if any, he or she could earn in an alternate circumstance.

The preferable strategy in lieu of imputation is to create some kind of incentive for the other spouse to get a higher paying job (or more typically, any job at all).  If this requires a lump-sum offer, you will still likely save money in the long-term.

After the needs of one spouse are established, the courts then look to the capacity of the other spouse to contribute to meet whatever deficit exists in that party’s ability to meet those needs themselves. “A spouse’s ability to pay may be determined not only from net income but from net worth, past earnings and the value of the parties’ capital assets.” Canakaris v Canakarais, 382 So. 2d 1197 (Fla. 1980)

Therefore, a party may have expensive needs and little to no income but the assets awarded to the party in a divorce may be sufficient to satisfy those needs and thus eliminate the need for an alimony award.

It is common for the higher-earning party to have a diminution or interruption of their income during a divorce proceeding to reduce their capacity to contribute to the other party’s alimony.  If this happens to you, you should preserve any and all evidence of the reasons for your income’s reduction.  Otherwise, the court will presume you are purposefully reducing your income and merely impute your previous income when the court calculates alimony.

Contact my Naples, Florida family law office today to schedule a free consultation with a divorce lawyer regarding the alimony you may have to receive or pay in your pending divorce.

Speak with a Lawyer

Schedule a FREE, no-obligation consultation with one of our attorneys.

Recent Posts

Can I see my husband or wife's text messages
Can My Husband Or Wife See My Text Messages?

A million questions swirl in the mind of the soon to be divorced. What will happen to my kids? What will happen to my retirement money? And, perhaps more immediately, can my husband or wife see my text messages?  What Are Text Messages? At the time of this writing,

Read More →
Can I Get An Annulment In Florida?

What does an annulment in Florida really mean? Black’s Law Dictionary defines an annulment as “when an event or judgment is treated as if it never happened” So, an annulment makes a marriage disappear as though it never existed.  This means you or your spouse cannot

Read More →
Free Consultation Divorce Lawyer Naples, Florida
Divorce Attorneys in Naples FL with Free Consultations

Naples, Florida lawyers with free consultations are rare but I am one of them.  Many other divorce lawyers in Naples do not offer free consultations.  Whether offering a free consultation is a signal for the quality (or lack thereof) of a divorce lawyer depends on a

Read More →